‘Our Baby Only Calms With His Father’: Malta Reels as Mother Begs Court to Spare Violent Ex

**Mother’s Plea Shakes Malta: ‘Our Baby Only Calms With His Father’ Sparks Soul-Searching Over Domestic Violence**

A courtroom in Valletta fell silent last week when a 26-year-old Maltese mother, her lip still split from a punch delivered in front of their toddler, asked Magistrate Marse-Ann Farrugia to spare her ex-partner prison. “Jien ma nridux ħabs għalih,” she whispered in Maltese, clutching a baby-grow smeared with the father’s scent. “Our son stops crying only when he hears his voice.” The plea, captured by Times of Malta and replayed endlessly on Lovin Malta’s Instagram reels, has detonated a national conversation about the island’s entrenched “kullħadd jaħdem għall-familja” (everyone works for the family) culture—and the price women pay to keep the mosaic intact.

Malta’s domestic-violence hotline 179 received 1,892 calls in 2023, a 38 % jump since 2020, yet only 7 % ended in charges. NGOs say the gap is cultural: church-led reconciliation sessions still outnumber police referrals in rural villages like Żejtun and Għargħur. “We’re told a child needs both parents at any cost,” explains Dr. Claudine Gatt, lawyer at the Commission on Gender-Based Violence. “That cost is often a woman’s face against a kitchen wall.” The mother in question—identified only as “Chantelle” to protect the child—was hospitalised twice in Qormi before moving to the Għajnsielem shelter, only to return when the 18-month-old refused to eat unless daddy sang *Għanja* lullabies via WhatsApp voice-note.

The case also exposes Malta’s unique custody paradox. EU data show Maltese fathers are awarded joint physical custody in 64 % of contested cases, the bloc’s highest rate. Lawyers privately admit magistrates favour “continued paternal bond” even when Protection Orders are active. “Foreign courts ask ‘Is he safe?’” says family therapist Maria Camilleri. “Maltese courts ask ‘Will the child lose his heritage?’” Chantelle’s ex faces up to three years for grievous bodily harm, but the defence argues imprisonment would “deprive a Maltese boy of his roots” ahead of his first *festa* in Nadur next month.

Outside the law, village Facebook groups are split. One Ħamrun thread—since deleted—called Chantelle “selfish” for “using a baby as a weapon”. Conversely, activist group #MovimentGħoxrin organised a 300-strong candle-light vigil outside the law courts on Thursday, brandishing posters: *“L-ulied ma jaħbnux il-vjolenza”* (Children don’t hide violence). The protest ended with a spontaneous *kant tal-bagħal* folk song, traditionally sung at funerals, reworded to honour women who stay “for the kids”. Speaker Angele Deguara warned: “When we glorify martyred mothers, we create future killers.”

Government reaction has been swift, if symbolic. Parliamentary Secretary Rebecca Buttigieg announced €350,000 for “therapeutic supervised contact rooms” where violent fathers can see children through one-way mirrors. But critics note the pilot centre—tucked inside the former Castille maternity ward—has just two rooms for an island of 520,000. “It’s like putting a plaster on a fractured *għonnella*,” quips sociologist Dr. Michael Briguglio, referencing the traditional Maltese veil once used to silence women.

Meanwhile, Chantelle’s plea has already inspired copy-cat requests. Two separate mothers in Birkirkara and Żabbar cited the Valletta hearing when withdrawing assault complaints this week. Police sources tell *Hot Malta* the phenomenon is being nicknamed “the calming effect defence”. Children’s commissioner Pauline Miceli urged caution: “Attachment can be re-built; broken bones cannot.”

The court will hand down sentence on 15 July, feast of Santa Marija, when Maltese towns erupt in fireworks celebrating motherhood. Whatever the outcome, the sound of a baby’s cry echoing through courtroom 4 has shattered the islands’ oldest myth: that blood ties trump black eyes. As the Għajnsielem shelter’s farewell card reads: *“Jekk il-kelma ‘mama’ titqies ta’ qerda, m’hemmx pajjiż li jista’ jgħix.”* If the word ‘mama’ is synonymous with destruction, no nation can survive.

—