On-the-spot fines: A step forward, but encroachment persists, say action groups

Picture this: You’re strolling along Republic Street in Valletta, Malta’s bustling capital, and you spot a vendor selling souvenirs right outside the Grandmaster’s Palace. You might think, “Finally, some action against encroachment!” But hold that thought. While on-the-spot fines have indeed started to make an impact, action groups argue that they’re just a band-aid on a much larger issue.

On-the-spot fines: A breath of fresh air

Introduced in 2019, on-the-spot fines have been a breath of fresh air in Malta’s ongoing battle against encroachment. The fines, ranging from €50 to €500, have been a deterrent for many vendors who previously operated with impunity. The Malta Tourism Authority (MTA) has been actively enforcing these fines, with over 1,000 issued in 2021 alone.

Take, for instance, the case of the popular tourist spot, Sliema Promenade. Since the introduction of on-the-spot fines, the once congested promenade has seen a significant reduction in vendors, making way for a more enjoyable experience for locals and tourists alike.

But encroachment persists, say action groups

While on-the-spot fines have been effective in some areas, action groups argue that the problem is far from solved. Encroachment, they say, is a symptom of deeper issues that these fines fail to address.

Take the case of the recently formed ‘Valletta is Ours’ group. They argue that the root cause of encroachment is the lack of proper infrastructure and planning. “Vendors aren’t the problem,” says group spokesperson, Maria Grech, “They’re just filling a void left by poor planning. We need to address the root cause, not just the symptoms.”

Similarly, the ‘Sliema Residents’ Association’ points out that encroachment is not just a nuisance but also a safety hazard. They’ve reported incidents where vendors’ stalls blocked emergency exits, posing a risk to public safety.

What’s the solution?

Action groups propose a multi-pronged approach. They suggest creating proper marketplaces where vendors can operate legally and safely. They also call for stricter enforcement of existing laws, including the Public Health Act and the Local Councils Act, which prohibit encroachment.

they advocate for better planning and infrastructure. “We need to create spaces that cater to both vendors and the public,” says Grech. “Spaces that are safe, clean, and enjoyable for everyone.”

In response, the MTA has assured the public that they are working on a long-term strategy to tackle encroachment. This includes the creation of designated market areas and the enforcement of existing laws.

However, action groups remain cautious. “We’ve heard these promises before,” says a spokesperson for the ‘Sliema Residents’ Association’, “What we need now is action, not just words.”

So, while on-the-spot fines have been a step in the right direction, the battle against encroachment is far from over. It’s clear that a broad approach is needed, one that addresses the root causes and not just the symptoms.

, let’s hope that the authorities, action groups, and the public can come together to create a solution that benefits everyone. After all, Malta’s streets are not just for vendors, they’re for all of us.